In custom apparel, both sublimation printing and screen printing are excellent methods for creating vibrant, personalized products. However, they achieve their effects in completely different ways, and each is better suited to different application scenarios. This blog post details the differences between sublimation vs screen printing to help you make the best choice.
Table of Contents
I. What Is Sublimation Printing?
II. What Is Screen Printing?
III. Dye Sublimation vs Screen Printing: Rapid Overview
IV. Sublimation vs Screen Printing: What's the Difference?
V. Screen Print vs Sublimation Print: Which to Choose?
VI. Other Printing Methods: Quick Guide & FAQs
I. What Is Sublimation Printing?
Sublimation is a digital, heat-transfer process.
Your design is mirrored and printed onto special transfer paper using sublimation ink (containing solid dye particles). Then, a heat press is used to transfer the design onto your garment using high temperature and pressure.
During the heat transfer process, the high temperature causes the solid dye particles on the paper to directly transform into gas; this change is called sublimation. The gas then permeates into your garment, cools, and solidifies again, becoming a permanent part of it.
Advantages
- Unmatched Durability and Feel: The design blends seamlessly with the fabric; you won't feel the print. It won't crack, peel, or fade, and it won't leave any texture.
- Full-Color, Photographic Detail: It can seamlessly reproduce designs with gradients and complex multi-color effects.
- Low Minimums and Flexibility: There are no screens or plates to make, making it suitable for single items or small batches. Design changes are also simple and affordable.
Disadvantages
- Fabric Limitations: Only effective on polyester fabrics (typically 85%+ polyester) and polymer-coated items such as mugs and plates. Furthermore, it is ineffective on 100% cotton or dark-colored garments.
- Start-Up Cost: Requires a sublimation printer, a heat press, and specific inks and paper.
II. What Is Screen Printing?
Screen printing is a manual, analog stenciling technique.
First, a mesh screen is created for each color in your design. Then, ink is poured onto the screen, and a squeegee is used to force the ink through the open mesh areas onto the garment below. Each color is applied one at a time, with drying or curing steps in between.
Advantages
- Versatile Fabric Compatibility: Suitable for cotton, cotton blends, and various fabrics, including dark-colored fabrics.
- Vibrant, Opaque Color: Plastisol inks (common in screen printing) sit on top of the fabric, creating bold, vibrant layers that are highly opaque.
- High-Volume Cost Efficiency: While setup is labor and cost-intensive, the per-unit cost drops dramatically for large runs, typically 50+ pieces.
Disadvantages
- Complex Setup, Higher Minimums: Each color requires a separate screen and setup, resulting in higher per-piece costs for small orders.
- Design Limitations: Suitable for simple designs; intricate patterns or gradient effects are difficult and expensive to reproduce.
- Texture: The ink layer has a noticeable, classic "printed" feel on the fabric.
III. Dye Sublimation vs Screen Printing: Rapid Overview
The table below provides a quick comparison of dye-sublimation printing and screen printing.
|
Aspect |
Sublimation Printing |
Screen Printing |
|
Process |
Digital; dye gas infuses fabric. |
Physical; ink is layered through screens. |
|
Durability/Feel |
Excellent. No cracking; zero-handle feel. |
Excellent. May crack over time; tactile feel. |
|
Best Fabric |
White/light-colored polyester (85% or more) |
Cotton, blends, various fabrics. |
|
Design Style |
Unlimited colors, photographs, gradients. |
Spot colors, bold graphics, text. |
|
Cost Driver |
Low setup, higher unit cost. Best for small runs. |
High setup, low unit cost. Best for bulk. |
|
Typical Turnaround |
Faster for prototypes/small batches. |
Longer setup, faster printing in bulk. |
|
Environmental Impact |
Less waste (no screens/chemicals). |
More chemicals (inks, emulsions, washouts). |
Sublimation printing is ideal for light-colored polyester fabrics and projects requiring full-color, photographic designs. It's suitable for small to medium runs and is simpler to set up than screen printing.
In contrast, screen printing is well-suited for cotton garments and bold designs with limited colors. It's more economical per piece for medium to large batch production and is faster than sublimation printing once set up.
IV. Sublimation vs Screen Printing: What's the Difference?
They differ mainly in manufacturing processes, fabrics, durability, feel, cost, and applicable scenarios.
1. Durability and Feel
This is the main difference between sublimation and screen printing, determined by their respective technical characteristics.
Sublimation inks integrate the design into the fabric polymer, preventing the pattern from cracking. Even after more than 50+ washes, a sublimation-printed jersey will retain its vibrant colors and soft touch.
Screen printing, on the other hand, coats the fabric surface with a layer of ink, resulting in a distinctly textured feel. High-quality plastisol inks, if cured properly, are also very durable. However, with repeated wear and washing, this ink layer may develop fine cracks.
2. Fabrics and Design
Dye-sublimation printing has virtually no limitations; it can easily print content from a screen, such as photographs, subtle gradients, or even millions of colors. The only constraint is that the design must be printed on a light background.
Screen printing excels at handling sharp, solid-color graphics. However, each additional color adds a screen, setup time, and cost. A 6-color design will cost far more than a 2-color design, and it is challenging and expensive to replicate fine details or smooth gradients using traditional screen printing.
3. Cost and Quantity
The cost difference between dye-sublimation printing and screen printing depends on the print run.
Sublimation printing has low setup costs; it only requires printing on transfer paper. The main costs include blank item, ink, and paper. The cost per shirt is relatively stable; printing 1 shirt might cost only $10, while printing 50 shirts might cost only $8 each.
Screen printing takes a different approach: setup is expensive, with a 4-color design typically requiring $80 to $120 for screen setup. However, once set up, printing speed is fast. The first shirt incurs the entire setup cost, but by the 100th shirt, the cost per shirt can drop to $4-5.
The cost break-even point is usually between 50 and 100 pieces. Below this number, sublimation is generally cheaper. Above this number, screen printing is more economical.
4. Speed and Scale
Sublimation allows for faster processing of samples and small-batch orders. From final design to finished product, it takes only a few hours, making it ideal for on-demand production and rapid prototyping.
In contrast, screen printing has a longer pre-production phase, including separating colors, burning screens, and setting up the press. However, once the press is up and running, a skilled crew can print hundreds of shirts per hour. This makes screen printing unmatched for large, standardized orders.
5. Environmental Impact
From an environmental standpoint, sublimation printing is generally cleaner. It uses dye-based inks with no solvents, produces no direct waste during printing, and doesn't require chemical clean-up.
Screen printing traditionally uses plastisol inks (PVC-based) that require chemical cleaners for screens. The process of screen reclaiming also generates wastewater that must be properly managed.
V. Screen Print vs Sublimation Print: Which to Choose?
The appropriate printing technology depends primarily on the fabric, print quantity, and design complexity.
1. Your Fabric: If you are using polyester or polymer-coated item, sublimation printing is ideal. If your garments are made of cotton, cotton blends, or other natural fibers, screen printing is more suitable.
2. Your Order Quantity: For orders of less than 50 pieces, sublimation printing is more cost-effective due to minimal setup costs. For orders of more than 50 pieces, screen printing is more advantageous because the higher initial setup cost can be amortized across the product quantity, thus reducing the unit price.
3. Your Design Complexity: If your design is a full-color photograph or contains complex gradients, you will need to use sublimation printing (for polyester) or alternatives such as DTF (for cotton). If your design contains several solid colors, such as logos or bold text, screen printing is more advantageous in terms of both quality and cost.
VI. Other Printing Methods: Quick Guide & FAQs
While dye-sublimation and screen printing dominate, other technologies also have their place:
- Heat Transfer Vinyl (HTV): A favorite among DIY enthusiasts. Colored vinyl sheets are cut into various shapes using a cutter such as Cricut, and then printed onto clothing via heat pressing. Best for simple, single-color designs on various fabrics.
- Direct-to-Garment (DTG): Similar to a giant inkjet printer for fabric. It prints water-based ink directly onto clothing. Best suited for creating one-off full-color designs on light-colored cotton, but with a higher unit cost and less durability than screen printing.
- Direct-to-Film (DTF): An emerging hybrid technology. The design is printed onto a special film with an adhesive, then transferred to the fabric by heat. It can provide near-sublimation color detail on a variety of fabrics, including cotton, and also offers good durability for small batches.
1. What is the best printing method for T-shirts?
For cotton T-shirts, screen printing is suitable for bulk orders of simple designs, while DTF is ideal for small batches of full-color designs. If you want to print on polyester sports T-shirts, sublimation printing is a better choice.
2. Which lasts longer, screen printing or sublimation?
As mentioned earlier, both are durable on suitable fabrics. However, because sublimation printing infuses the garment rather than sitting on top, it retains its softness for longer.
3. Can a Cricut do sublimation printing?
Cricut is a cutting machine; it's involved in sublimation printing: precisely cutting the printed sublimation transfer paper for perfect positioning. However, it cannot print with sublimation ink, nor can it heat-transfer patterns. To achieve true sublimation, you need a heat press to permanently bond the pattern to the garment.
VII. The Bottom Line
Choose between dye-sublimation printing vs screen printing to best suit your specific needs. If you're using polyester, require realistic designs, have medium to small order quantities, and prioritize a soft and durable finished product, then dye-sublimation printing is ideal. If you're using cotton, have bold designs with limited colors, need hundreds of pieces, and are seeking a classic, vibrant, and textured look, then screen printing is the best option.
Keep Exploring: More Blogs to Dive Into
